Re: Supporters’ Liaison Group; some questions
Posted: 16 Apr 2018, 16:14
Hi MCB,
I can only answer from what I know or have experienced
Does anyone from the old Supporters Association know the kind of losses incurred by the association / club in running a full season of away coaches?
At a meeting 2 or 3 years ago (my memory is not what it was) TK said the loss was equal to half a reasonable squad player, and from my experience the losses must have become greater as time went on.
Also wondering what it would take to have a Supporters Club that had everyone's support - none of the hostility of the old trust / club, as there is universal support for the fact that we need one, and the Supporters’ Liaison Group is a poor alternative.
What a good question. I believe even when times were good the membership in numbers was, I seem to recall, about 10% of our average home attendance but I may well be wrong and hope someone corrects me.
i.e.... what would be broadly supportive and allow us to move forward and have bite? Things that spring to mind:
- A constitution that believes in a spiritual desire to return to the Borough of Barnet (without placing any emphasis on making it happen in the short term) But wouldn't this exclude supporters who live locally, those who now have a preference for the Hive although granted there is nothing to compare it to presently in the Borough of Barnet, those who now have an easier journey than Underhill and, I guess, other reasons.
- Independence to the club but a commitment to support it
- Improved supporters representation at the club (i.e. an aim to have a supporter on the board) This is the aim of a Trust
- Priority on improving the supporters experience (including running coach services), and a focus on growing support (especially for children) TK approved a supporters Trust as it legally gave those running it protection should things go wrong, i.e. something to do with organising coach travel. This protection is something a Supporters Association would not have
- Ensuring the club survives for another 130 years through financial security (and long term aim of ownership - the old Supporters Club already has a small % of shares in Barnet FC which I guess are in limbo) I agree
- Regular meetings with the chairman / club (i.e. bi-monthly) to put forward members opinions. We have quarterly meetings so this shouldn't prove to be a problem. The difficulty comes in deciding which of several opinions would be put forward
- Run events like player of the year? This would need to be discussed with the Chairman
This for example is the Arsenal Independent Supporters’ Association rather bland but appropriate constitution: http://www.fsf.org.uk/assets/Downloads/ ... nrules.pdf To be honest I haven't looked but will when I have more time
Is it possible to move forward without re-opening the wounds of the past? To accept that we the fans and club would be stronger with a club? Would there be sufficient people prepared to throw their hats into the ring? I believe the first thing to decide upon is Supporters Association or Trust and I'm the wrong person to advise (memory issue). Then people would be fully aware of what is expected and then a recruitment drive could start. However I did throw out the suggestion of forming a Trust on here and on BTID on Facebook. One person replied positively and another offered help whenever he could. Is there demand?
Something that someone else mentioned prior would be something like a £2 a month level of membership (a 500 club or so) that would fund it, and cover the losses of coaches, or a one off annual payment (£15 adults £5 juniors). Good idea but Treasurer needed!
I'm not a coach user for away journeys, but I think it's important for the club & the players (if we can get over the pick up issues). Do users of the Percy Bus know if the aim is for it always to run independently, or if a Supporters Club ran a coach those users would use it?Only Steve can answer that. I think Steve has his loyal customers who enjoy the days out he offers which is not what some want. When the SA ran the coaches I understand it was used mainly by the older generation who now no longer travel anyway. When the club first started with the coaches we had a good turnout including quite a few youngsters. These youngsters have now grown up and, like many others, prefer the relaxed alcohol rules trains offer as well as very good fares if booked soon enough.There are times,(away evening games for instance) when a coach would come into it's own but the team's form has lot to do with many supporterl.
Anyway, the above are just thoughts, not opinions. Just wondering how things can move forward.
MCB, these are only my thoughts and I'd be happy to discuss them further with you if you'd like but the big question is 'Is a supporters organisation actually wanted'? For me, I'd say yes - but I'm only me.
I can only answer from what I know or have experienced
Does anyone from the old Supporters Association know the kind of losses incurred by the association / club in running a full season of away coaches?
At a meeting 2 or 3 years ago (my memory is not what it was) TK said the loss was equal to half a reasonable squad player, and from my experience the losses must have become greater as time went on.
Also wondering what it would take to have a Supporters Club that had everyone's support - none of the hostility of the old trust / club, as there is universal support for the fact that we need one, and the Supporters’ Liaison Group is a poor alternative.
What a good question. I believe even when times were good the membership in numbers was, I seem to recall, about 10% of our average home attendance but I may well be wrong and hope someone corrects me.
i.e.... what would be broadly supportive and allow us to move forward and have bite? Things that spring to mind:
- A constitution that believes in a spiritual desire to return to the Borough of Barnet (without placing any emphasis on making it happen in the short term) But wouldn't this exclude supporters who live locally, those who now have a preference for the Hive although granted there is nothing to compare it to presently in the Borough of Barnet, those who now have an easier journey than Underhill and, I guess, other reasons.
- Independence to the club but a commitment to support it
- Improved supporters representation at the club (i.e. an aim to have a supporter on the board) This is the aim of a Trust
- Priority on improving the supporters experience (including running coach services), and a focus on growing support (especially for children) TK approved a supporters Trust as it legally gave those running it protection should things go wrong, i.e. something to do with organising coach travel. This protection is something a Supporters Association would not have
- Ensuring the club survives for another 130 years through financial security (and long term aim of ownership - the old Supporters Club already has a small % of shares in Barnet FC which I guess are in limbo) I agree
- Regular meetings with the chairman / club (i.e. bi-monthly) to put forward members opinions. We have quarterly meetings so this shouldn't prove to be a problem. The difficulty comes in deciding which of several opinions would be put forward
- Run events like player of the year? This would need to be discussed with the Chairman
This for example is the Arsenal Independent Supporters’ Association rather bland but appropriate constitution: http://www.fsf.org.uk/assets/Downloads/ ... nrules.pdf To be honest I haven't looked but will when I have more time
Is it possible to move forward without re-opening the wounds of the past? To accept that we the fans and club would be stronger with a club? Would there be sufficient people prepared to throw their hats into the ring? I believe the first thing to decide upon is Supporters Association or Trust and I'm the wrong person to advise (memory issue). Then people would be fully aware of what is expected and then a recruitment drive could start. However I did throw out the suggestion of forming a Trust on here and on BTID on Facebook. One person replied positively and another offered help whenever he could. Is there demand?
Something that someone else mentioned prior would be something like a £2 a month level of membership (a 500 club or so) that would fund it, and cover the losses of coaches, or a one off annual payment (£15 adults £5 juniors). Good idea but Treasurer needed!
I'm not a coach user for away journeys, but I think it's important for the club & the players (if we can get over the pick up issues). Do users of the Percy Bus know if the aim is for it always to run independently, or if a Supporters Club ran a coach those users would use it?Only Steve can answer that. I think Steve has his loyal customers who enjoy the days out he offers which is not what some want. When the SA ran the coaches I understand it was used mainly by the older generation who now no longer travel anyway. When the club first started with the coaches we had a good turnout including quite a few youngsters. These youngsters have now grown up and, like many others, prefer the relaxed alcohol rules trains offer as well as very good fares if booked soon enough.There are times,(away evening games for instance) when a coach would come into it's own but the team's form has lot to do with many supporterl.
Anyway, the above are just thoughts, not opinions. Just wondering how things can move forward.
MCB, these are only my thoughts and I'd be happy to discuss them further with you if you'd like but the big question is 'Is a supporters organisation actually wanted'? For me, I'd say yes - but I'm only me.